Date | Venue / Stadium | Time | Attendance |
| 12 October 2012 | Toronto / BMO Field | 19:45 | 17712 |
Referee Javier SANTOS (PUR) | Assistant Referee 1 Antonio LOPEZ (PUR) |
Fourth Official William ANDERSON (PUR) | Assistant Referee 2 Jairo MORALES (PUR) |
| a.e.t.: | After extra time | (C): | Captain | PSO: | Penalty Shoot-out |
| GK: | Goalkeeper | N: | Not eligible to play | I: | Injured |
| Y: | Misses next match if booked | Pos: | Positions | A: | Absent |